This is a guest article from Denis K. of Cigar Inspector. It is part of the Cigars 101 series on EG.
—
There are few things that shout masculinity and sophistication quite like a cigar, and cigars truly are among the finer pleasures in life.
If you delight in your senses, you may well become a connoisseur of cigars, but a lot depends on your very first stogie.
If you choose something you are not going to enjoy, pay too much for your first stick, or expect your first experience to be perfect, you may as well turn away from the wonderful world of cigars before you realize what you’re missing.
To ensure that doesn’t happen to you, I’m providing you with my list of suggestions for your first cigar.
You also probably want to check out my advice for smoking a cigar without looking like an idiot and properly storing your cigars in a humidor.
Price
First thing’s first, let’s go over some general advice for choosing your first cigar.
You probably should look to spend around $5-$8 on your first stogie. You can get a very good cigar for this price, but you won’t break the bank, and you are less likely to get discouraged if the cigar doesn’t live up to your initial expectations.
Odds are your first smoking experience is going to be less than ideal since you are still learning. You probably want to save up your money for a higher end stogie once you have got the hang of it.
Is Mild a Hard and Fast Rule?
In this price range, you will find a lot of choices. Many websites recommend you stick to something mild for your first go-round. If in doubt, go for it.
If, however, you enjoy strong coffee or you are an ex-cigarette smoker, you would probably be just fine with a medium-bodied stick or even a full-bodied one. If your taste is for something stronger, you may find a mild cigar bland, tasteless, and unmemorable.
If you do go for something mild in this case, you should look for a stogie with reviews suggesting it is a good all-around stick for everyone, with enough complexity to hold the interest of a smoker who generally prefers medium- or full-bodied smokes.
If you can’t make up your mind, another idea is to try picking out several different sticks which interest you, going for a range of mild, medium, and full-bodied smokes.
You can start out with the mild cigar, and if you find it bland, you may well find the medium or full-bodied smokes more compelling. If you stay within the price range I suggested, this is not a huge investment, but it will help you find what you truly enjoy.
Where to Buy Your First Cigar
The cigars I suggest below are all widely available at brick and mortar shops and online. Whatever you do, do not buy your first cigar (or any cigar) at a gas station, convenience store, or similar location.
Those cigars may be cheap, but they are not properly stored in a humidor, which means that you are not getting a high-quality cigar. It will rob you of the essence of the cigar experience, and you will end up regretting it.
If at all possible, do your shopping at a B&M where you can get some beginner’s advice from the humidor staff. Tobacconists are generally very friendly and happy to provide suggestions to new smokers.
And now let’s move onto the meat of this article—my suggestions!
Top 5 Cigars for New Smokers
Avo Classic
Avo is one of the best-known cigar brands in the world, created by pianist Avo Uvezian after he went into the cigar business.
Avo Classic cigars are mild, creamy blends in Connecticut wrappers. While they are not the most complex sticks out there, they offer a consistent, enjoyable, and relaxing experience and are perfect for a novice in search of something mild.
CAO Gold Vintage
CAO is another worldwide bestselling cigar brand.
CAO Gold Vintage cigars are enclosed in Ecuadorian Connecticut wrappers grown in 2004, a particularly good year (I wonder how they manage to keep producing cigars with this wrapper though), with a combination of Cuban-seed Honduran and Nicaraguan tobacco inside.
This cigar offers a smooth, creamy, mild flavor with subtle nutty flavors. The blend takes on a medium-bodied character as you progress, so if you cannot decide between a mild- or medium-bodied cigar for your first smoke, this is a perfect choice.
Ashton Aged Maduro
Ashton cigars are acclaimed globally for their high level of quality.
The Ashton Aged Maduro offers a good starting point for a beginner who is open to a full-bodied experience and wants to try a good maduro (a cigar with a dark, maduro wrapper leaf).
Consistent spice, coffee flavors, and notes of leather, nuts, and lime create a complex and enjoyable blend.
Rocky Patel Edge Lite
Rocky Patel is a boutique cigar manufacturer who has risen to prominence in the premium cigar world despite the odds, and it’s thanks largely to amazing blends like this one.
The Rocky Patel Edge Lite is a medium- to full-bodied cigar with a rich, creamy flavor and an excellent draw and burn.
It only costs $5, which makes it a great choice for a cigar newbie.
Oliva Connecticut Reserve & Oliva Serie G
Oliva is best known for manufacturing delicious full-bodied cigars.
The Serie G Maduro is a great example, with a dark oily wrapper and amazingly rich chocolate and coffee flavors against a backdrop of toasted nuts.
If you’re interested in Oliva but prefer to try something milder, the Connecticut Reserve is a light-to-medium bodied cigar with flavors of butter and toasted almonds.
While it’s a milder smoke, it’s hardly dull or unmemorable, and is quite flavorful and aromatic.
Bonus for International Readers
Have access to Cubans and looking for an affordable cigar that can deliver an awesome experience?
The Partagas Shorts cost $6-$8 for a stick (you might need to add 2x that amount for taxes though, depending on where you live), offers great construction, and a delicious blend of flavors: sweet latte combined with chocolate, vanilla, honey, wood, and spice.
Once you’ve tried these cigars, you will get a better idea of what you enjoy.
Honorable Mentions
Some other cigars worth mentioning are the Alec Bradley American Classic, Perdomo Lot 23, Padron X000 Series, Montecristo White, 5 Vegas Gold, and Cabaiguan.
Enjoy your first cigar, but don’t forget to pick up several and give it at least a few tries if you don’t like your first one. Many smokers find their first attempt at smoking a bit awkward, and enjoy their second and third cigars much more than their first.
The world of cigars is quite extensive and if you find you enjoy it here, you will discover a friendly and eager community of cigar aficionados who are bursting to offer up suggestions and introduce you to their favorite smokes.
—
Thanks, Denis! I still consider myself a novice in the cigar world, despite enjoying them for a number of years now. I appreciate these suggestions and there are quite a few of them I still have to try.
Over to you
I know there are quite a number of readers who enjoy cigars from time to time—you seem to be silent in the comments until the cigar-related posts are published —so I’d love to hear from you.
Have you tried any of these sticks? If you’re still a budding cigar connoisseur, which ones are you most looking forward to trying?
Excited to hear from you in the comments below!
As always, I’m sure Denis would love to have you over in his little corner of the internet. You can visit Cigar Inspector and do some exploring.
photos via Cigar Inspector