It’s five answers to five questions. Here we go…
1. Can I drop out of a leadership program that’s the opposite of what I want?
I was nominated to join a leadership program at my company by my department’s management team. When I was told about the nomination by my manager, he emphasized how great this opportunity was for me.
At face value, I had some reservations: I cannot stress how little ambition I have. I have zero interest in any sort of management role (people or project), and I think I’d choose the acid bath over a networking event. But my manager was excited and since I had previously expressed my lack of interest in management (and also I thought expressed my general unsociable nature), I thought this thing couldn’t be all that bad.
The introduction meeting happened the other day and I am reeling. The whole program is based around proactive networking. It seemed like most of the others in this program are the bubbly, assertive types. Very eager to chit chat, very happy to play host for events, very bend over backwards to express how excited they are. That is just not and could never be me. I have a very small social battery I like to preserve for outside of work. I just want to do my job, make enough money for a roof over my and my cats’ heads, and pay for my silly little vices.
I don’t know what to do. I feel like my manager should know that this is a total clash with my personality, but he signed me up for this. I’m afraid of disappointing him, but I’m also thinking to protect my peace I need to tell him something. Can I outright request to not participate in this program? And … how do I do that?
You can probably drop out, but there’s likely to be some cost to doing it after you’ve already started. There could be some exceptions to this; I’ve had bosses where I could have said, “Thanks for thinking of me for this but after attending the first class it’s clear it’s very much not for me” and it would have been fine. But unless you know for sure that you have that type of relationship with your boss, dropping out does have some political risk.
Can you go back to your boss and ask what made him want to nominate you for the program? You could say that so far it seems out of sync with the interests you’ve talked about with him and so you’re curious to hear his thinking, and then hear him out with an open mind. I do worry that it’ll turn out that it’s because he knows you don’t like this stuff that he thought it would be “good for you” … but who knows, maybe there’s more to it than that.
As for what to do after that, weigh how much of a pain it’s really going to be. If it’s just sitting through a few annoying classes, it’s probably worth sucking it up and getting through it. But if it’s going to demand significantly more from you(like if you’re going to have to organize events, go to networking stuff, etc.), there’s more of an argument for considering spending some capital on opting out.
2. Is it OK that I don’t work while I’m on a pumping break?
I had my first baby and came back to work about three months ago. I’m breastfeeding, so I take 20-30 minutes two or three times per day to pump. I try to schedule my sessions around meetings and other job duties. If there’s a meeting I can’t miss I’ll call in or I’ll bring my laptop into the pumping room to work on a project, but most of the time I read or play games on my phone. I’m wondering if it’s okay to use my pumping sessions as also a sort of break. I’m willing to do what needs to get done, but we’re also in a slow season and I don’t like working while pumping! Pumping is work, and not nearly as nice as actually feeding my baby at home. (I am also slightly resentful that my company revoked our two WFH days right before I went on parental leave, so now I have to drive in and pump five days/week.) Can you please give me and all other pumping parents permission to chill out guilt-free for a bit while we work to feed our kiddos?
(The only reason I wouldn’t be pumping while working at home is that my partner works four 10-hour shifts, including one weekend day, so he is home with the baby those two days I’m now required to be in the office.)
You can indeed continue what you’re doing, guilt-free. The law gives you breaks to pump and they are truly breaks, not just time when you’re supposed to keep working while hooked up to a machine. Plus, a lot of people who pump find they can’t pump successfully if they’re trying to work at the same time; some women need to look at a photo of their baby or otherwise relax in order to express milk. It’s fine to make it a real break from work.
3. Is prohibiting beards discrimination?
I’m curious about the Army and Marines removing the exemption to a standard for men’s grooming which had allowed men who couldn’t shave daily for medical reasons a waiver in which they could grow a short, neat beard. Obviously, they’d have to shave more regularly for operational duties, like if they were wearing gas masks, scuba masks, or any other equipment requiring a tight seal on the face. Since this rule disproportionately affects Black men, 45% of whom currently have this waiver compared to 3% of white men, I would think this would be an easy, and blatant, example of workplace discrimination. Am I right?
In theory, yes. The EEOC has found repeatedly that to comply with the Americans with Disabilities Act, employers must make exceptions to shaving policies for people who suffer from pseudofolliculitis barbae (which is common among black men and causes razor bumps that are at high risk for infection). The only exception is if there are clear safety reasons not to and even then they need to explore other accommodations if possible, such as changes in duties.
The protections for employees in Title VII don’t extend to uniformed members of the armed forces, so legally they can probably do this … but the choice is pretty revealing.
4. How important is volunteer work on a resume?
I used to volunteer with a local organization, but after the organization made some changes, that volunteer role was no longer needed. Since then, I lead a small local hobby group, but I don’t have any current volunteer positions with larger, more established organizations, and I’m not on any boards. Outside of that hobby group, I fill my spare time with solo hobbies like cooking, reading, and exercising, casual get-togethers with friends and family, and I’m also in a couple of book clubs. I feel fulfilled!
But will employers be looking for stronger evidence of leadership in my spare time when they look at my resume? I’m in a relatively senior role, so I’m wondering if that makes it more important.
For the vast majority of jobs, including senior ones, it’s absolutely fine not to include volunteer work on your resume. It can be a plus if you have it — especially if the work relates in some way to the job you’re applying for or showcases an ability that your paid job history is light on, but it’s not going to be a problem if you don’t have it. (Frankly, most people don’t do volunteer work; that’s more the norm than not.) There are a small number of jobs where demonstrating community involvement is more important, particularly C-level roles, but you’d almost certainly know if you were in one of them.
5. Layoff limbo: should I job search now if it means not getting severance?
I feel semi-stuck in a layoff limbo. My employer has been acquired by another company, but the transaction won’t happen for another 6-12 months. While management has been trying to be as transparent as possible, they obviously aren’t telling us yet if layoffs will happen, when, and what percentage of the workforce will be laid off in the acquisition process. I enjoy my job, I have a decent manager who lets me be autonomous, and I work fully remote. The best job in the world? No, but my workload is manageable, and I have no grievances to air.
However, with the uncertain future looming, I’ve been browsing LinkedIn job openings and do see a half dozen positions that I’d be eligible for that would also include a nice pay raise (20-50%). However, I don’t necessarily want to leave my current position if 1) it’s not getting eliminated, or 2) if it does end up getting eliminated and I’m eligible for severance pay. Obviously, severance packages haven’t even been discussed yet, so who knows if it’d be a flat amount, one week for every year of employment, or one month for every year of employment (I’d be shocked if it was as generous as that, but hey, I can dream). Multiple employers frequently hire for my position, so I really don’t have any fear of not finding a new job quickly. A fully remote job with a huge pay bump and interesting work? Maybe not. But I am fortunate and confident enough that I could find a quick lateral move nonetheless.
I feel stuck in limbo, though, because I may have up to 12 months for this process to take place. Do I just keep my head down and wait to see if I’m retained or laid off? Do I job hunt leisurely now and try to get a more lucrative and enticing job but risk not getting a severence package? Or do I wait until I know I’m getting laid off and then potentially having to accept the first okay job that falls into my lap? I feel like it’s probably the leisurely job search option, but I don’t want “job-hunter’s remorse” if I could have stayed in my position or gotten severence pay before jumping off the acquired ship. What advice do you have? Have any readers regretted leaving a job before being potentially laid off?
Start a leisurely search now. It’s extremely unlikely that severance would be as high as a month for every year of employment; one week, or maybe two weeks, per year is more typical, and it could be less than that. If the choice is between (a) a great new job with a good manager, remote work, and other benefits you want, but no severance or (b) severance but a more middling job with a problematic managers and inferior benefits … the first option is better, and is likely to improve your day-to-day quality of life for a longer period of time.
A leisurely search means you don’t need to take anything unless it really seems worth forgoing severance — but it’s smart to get a head start on looking around so that you can be picky about what you take.
The post can I drop out of a leadership program I hate, is prohibiting beards discrimination, and more appeared first on Ask a Manager.






The organization’s pointed new “












