The most thrilling New York discoveries tend to happen when you least expect them. That's especially true when it comes to exploring the city's insanely large (and ever-changing) restaurant and bar scene. Sometimes, the best spots can't be found by searching Zagat or Yelp. They're stumbled upon while you're simply walking the streets.
Remington Guest, brainchild behind the food-centric blog
Cheap, Best, Hidden — and, recent inductee into Tumblr's Class of 2015 for New York Fashion Week — has spent plenty of hours, days, and weeks scouring New York City for, in his own words, things like the "best damn croissants...or the place that will make frozen margaritas to go." Want to know the cool, under-the-radar spots he's uncovered? Ahead, Guest shares tips and tricks (like when to go and what to order) for 10 of the city's eateries.
Boxkite
"Coffee shops are the reason I started my blog. I’m a self-proclaimed chain coffee drinker. So, what’s better than a coffee shop that can drop a ten-course tasting on you, à la a chef's counter?
"Boxkite instantly became one of my go-to coffee shops with its espresso program — then moved into its own category after the dinner I had (which, by the way, included cider pairings with every course). Each dish not only had some of the most beautiful plating my young eyes have ever seen, but the flavors were shocking, new, modern, and delicious. I know it sounds like I just described a Tom Clancy novel, but it’s all from the heart. The plates that come out of this tiny coffee-shop kitchen are nothing short of miraculous."
Tip: "It's first come, first serve, but à la carte for the couple of stools in the window. Reservations are required for the chef’s table, which serves up a tasting menu Tuesday through Saturday."
Perfect For: "Coffee with a friend, grabbing a house-made pastry to go, or a date night."
Box Kite Coffee, 115 Saint Marks Place (between First Avenue and Avenue A); 212-574-8201.
Dirty French
"The Lower East Side just keeps getting cooler. It used to be cool because you could get mugged when you went, and it was a victory to make it out alive. Now, it’s cool because of places like Dirty French, one of the best spots to land below Houston since Stanton Social's glory days.
"You have to love a restaurant that makes some of the best cocktails in the city. The bread basket (which is not a bread basket, by the way, but a bowl of insane warm crepes) blew me away, as did the duck à l’orange, the lamb carpaccio (massive and impressive), the pommes frites, and the tuna tartare. Plus, the space is beautiful, like an incredibly fancy barn in Provence. Basically, I was sold from the get-go."
Tip: "Start at one of the bars, either in the restaurant or in the hotel lobby. They're run by the same mixologist as ZZ’s Clam Bar is, meaning there are some of the finest cocktails for your sipping pleasure."
Perfect For: "Special occasions, fancy cocktails, or dinner meetings."
Dirty French, 180 Ludlow Street (between East Houston and Stanton streets); 212-254-3000.
El Rey
"Local is always the way to go. And, El Rey is the definition of a local spot. Recently, they launched a menu with the kind of things you actually want to eat every day, at prices even a struggling food blogger — a.k.a., me — can afford.
"El Rey improves and serves a variety of popular dishes, dropping them right down in front of you with that rap battle attitude. Get there early to score one of the house-made pastries (they sell out quick), and make sure to order the avocado 'del sur' — a.k.a., sliced avocado dropped from heaven; it comes with chimichurri and hickory-smoked sea salt, and will have you rethinking your entire perspective on your favorite dish. By the way, the kale isn’t your average kale, so don’t pass on that either, just because you've been O.D.-ing on kale salad for the last three years."
Tip: "Go for tea in the evening, because it's really hard to find a good, chill spot for a nice warm cup after 7 p.m."
Perfect For: "Morning coffee and breakfast, a healthy (but delicious!) lunch, or a good ol' neighborhood beer (yes, this is a coffee shop with an incredible list of brews on tap)."
El Rey Coffee Bar & Luncheonette, 100 Stanton Street (at Ludlow Street); 212-260-3950.
Hi-Collar
"Hi-Collar is the most sleeper of places. You walk into the long, narrow space and feel like you’re in a luxury Japanese train car, which I imagine to all have long, metal counters and a sake bar.
"The coffee is made to order — literally, by the cup — and the food (like the pork katsu sandwich — which they only serve 10 of per day) is fantastic. The cakes (which are basically an inch and a half of fluff) are meticulously prepared in front of you and served with an incredible specialty butter."
Tip: "Bring cash; there's a $10 credit card minimum for lunch and $20 for bar service."
Perfect For: "An escape from New York, a hearty lunch, or when you're craving something sweet."
Hi-Collar, 214 East 10th Street (between First and Second avenues); 212-777-7018.
Nitecap
"I love hidden places like Nitecap on the Lower East Side. Enter through a small door on Rivington Street, and you'll be led downstairs to a dimly lit, moody little room. All the cocktails have rad names, like Peter Piper’s Pickled Peppered Pineapple, which is fun to make your too-drunk friend say five times fast.
"They also have an 'honor' bar situation, were you pick a bottle and pay for what you drink; the menu says, ‘a handshake, eye contact, and a credit card are required.’ It's like those houses on Halloween that leave garbage bins full of candy outside, with a tiny sign that says, 'Take 1.' Yeah, that never worked."
Tip: "Avoid long, late-night waits and go for apéritif hour (where drinks are $10!) from 6 to 8 p.m."
Perfect For: "After-work cocktails, a creative date, or late-night drinks."
Nitecap, 120 Rivington Street (between Essex and Norfolk streets); 212-466-3361.
Rose Bakery
"I have so much love for Dover Street Market. It's an international purveyor of unreal clothing worldwide, and the New York [outpost] has a Nike Lab.
"Inside, you'll find this London-based café, which is the real deal. The daily salads are [insert new word for fresh, because I refuse to use that played-out word anymore]. You can also get Blue Bottle coffee alongside some eggs (my favorite) and pastries (shout out to the scones!)."
Tip: "Order an egg dish; their scrambled eggs are extra-soft and fluffy."
Perfect For: "A coffee meeting or hanging at a cool place with cooler people."
Rose Bakery, 160 Lexington Avenue (at 30th Street); 646-837-7754.
Okonomi
"Fish for breakfast is definitely not the most appealing idea I've heard. But, that's what you'll get at this Japanese spot, which sources 90% of its seafood from the East Coast.
"You can see and taste the level of attention and care the chefs put into every single dish (my favorite is rice with added egg, salmon roe, and uni). There are about 12 seats in the place, and no one there is in a rush, so don't expect to run in and out (be prepared to wait even on a weekday). It has an air of calm that just can’t be bought."
Tip: "Okonomi switches to à la carte ramen service in the evening. That is obviously worth going to as well."
Perfect For: "A more exotic breakfast, a warm bowl of ramen, or being ahead of the trends (get here before it gets too popular!)."
Okonomi, 150 Ainslie Street (between Leonard and Lorimer streets); Brooklyn.
Glady's
"I don’t live in Crown Heights, but I am obsessed with Caribbean hotspot Glady’s. A good portion of the menu is crafted using Cuca Fresca, which is impressive alone, and it features tons of pure, simple Caribbean food — like jerk lobster, which is literally pulled from the tank to your plate in minutes."
Tip: "This place has tons of deals and steals. The lunch special includes 1/4 chicken or pork, rice and peas, spicy slaw, and plantains for $9; every day from 5:30 to 7 p.m., rum punch on tap is only $4; and on Tiki Tuesdays, there are $7 drink specials."
Perfect For: "Lunch, relaxing with a friend, or a first date."
Glady's Caribbean, 788 Franklin Avenue (at Lincoln Place), Brooklyn; 718-622-0249.
Animals
"Animals is one of those pop-ups that hasn’t gone away, which is perfect, because you would never want it to close. It has the most unreal sandwiches you’ll ever taste. My personal favorite is The Beast, which is beef braised in red wine, aromatics, and stone fruit, with pickled onions and horseradish creme. When’s the last time you had a sandwich with aromatics? Probably never. Also, don’t ignore the salads like an unsophisticated goob. The Brussels salad and cabbage salad would normally be easy to overlook: not here. Oh, and the fingerling potatoes are a must."
Tip: "Pop next door to The Wayland for a nightcap. It's one of the best bars in the city and shares the same owners."
Perfect For: "Lunch. I love to stay for hours, because the plating and atmosphere are killer."
Animals, 140 Avenue C (at East 9th Street); 212-777-7437.
Petee’s Pie Company
"I thought 2015 was all about prime rib, bone broth, and Indian spices. Is the pie trend making a comeback?!
"Well, forget these food trends. Petee's Pie just changed the game. Every dish on the menu is seasonal and local. The crust is made with grass-fed butter from Upstate. Hello, pie revival; R.I.P, cupcakes."
Tip: "Order everything you can. Don’t skip anything. The cinnamon buns are very rare (they're popular!). And, get a scoop of the goat-cheese ice cream."
Perfect For: "Pie, a quick lunch, or when you're looking for a little pick-me-up."
Petee’s Pie Company, 61 Delancey Street; 212-966-2526.
Like what you see?How about some more R29 goodness, right here?
Below-Freezing NYC Street Style That's Still Fire
Feeling Knotty: A Simple Way To Style Your Too-Big Clothes
Peep Inside NYC's Coolest Tiny Apartment