On which side do you stand in the Battle of the Books ?

Nathan Pyle/BuzzFeed
Six BuzzFeed employees engage in a vicious debate to decide which books are better, printed or electric. Moderated by Nathan Pyle.
Nathan Pyle: Many say, "E-books are a minor blip on history's radar — paper books have always and will continue to dominate." Thoughts?
Erica Futterman: There are so many things people dismissed as a passing fad that are now integral parts of how we live day-to-day.
Alanna Okun: I'm pretty platform agnostic, as it were, but I do feel like that kind of thinking is pretty reductive and head-in-the-sand — it's almost like saying the internet is a fad. Like, "I don't understand this so it probably doesn't matter."
Chelsea Marshall: I actually am team paper books, but don't think that whatever is dominant is what is better... So basically, e-books might be more dominant in the future but they will never be better for different reasons. (We can get into that later.)
Julia Pugachevsky: It's definitely not a fad, because it's helping the environment.
Chelsea: Is it, though? What about the factories?
Isaac Fitzgerald: Exactly. The "e" doesn't stand for "environment." How you charging these things? Coal? Nuclear power?
Krystie Yandoli: Logistically, it makes sense that books turn digital — newspapers, magazines, and every other aspect of publishing is following suit. It's not a fad — however, we won't be passing on our Kindles to our children and grandchildren and so forth. Links die and break and go away. If we don't have hard copies of things like we have up until this point ... Also, #OldBookSmell and paper books look really pretty on a bookshelf.
Isaac: Yes! What do we read when the apocalypse comes? How are you gonna charge that Kindle when all the energy from the earth is no more and all we have are cave paintings, fires, and books from the old days before the fall?
Krystie: Yeah!
Chelsea: Are you prepared for that fate?
Erica: Guys, we are redefining the future. Besides, I'm sure someone will create an apocalypse-friendly battery for when the time comes.

Nathan Pyle/BuzzFeed
View Entire List ›