
What's in a cocktail name? There are straightforward drinks that tell you exactly what you'll be sipping—"cucumber martini" leaves little to the imagination. But then there are the cocktails with more conversation-worthy titles. At Lantern's Keep, who
is the Wildest Redhead? And what is it that Any Major Dude Will Tell You at Vinegar Hill House?
We decided to find out what inspired some of the cocktails currently being shaken and stirred around NYC. Click through the above slide show for the stories and recipes, told to us by the bartenders who created the drinks.
Cousin Scotty Fails His Driving Test
Created by: Brian Bartels at
Chez Sardine
"I have a cousin named Scotty. He's two years older than me. I was in the same grade as Paul, his little brother. We were smartasses. Scotty was very excited the day he went to take his driver's test to achieve a legitimate Wisconsin Driver's License. I'll never forget when he came back home. It was something I have come to understand as "schadenfreude." Scotty came back and the first thing we saw was his keys flying across the kitchen and crashing into the wall. He stormed up the upstairs steps with his fists clenched and all Paul and I wanted to do was tease him for failing. This is what our families did best. If I'm not mistaken, it took Scotty three attempts to get his driver's license. My brother Tim, too. And my niece. So I guess it runs in our family."
Recipe:
Johnny Drum Bourbon
Carpano Antica Vermouth
House Sake-Agave Syrup
Angostura Bitters
Stirred in a mixing glass, then strained over ice into an old-fashioned glass; garnish with wide orange peel.
I Hear Banjos (Encore)
Created by: Jason Mendenhall at
The Wayland
"I Hear Banjo's (Encore) is the third iteration of one of the original—and most popular—cocktails served at The Wayland.
Deliverance is a great movie from the '70s about white-water rafting in the backwoods, and there's a guy picking a banjo throughout the movie. When I started to create the drink, the eerie sound of that banjo popped into my head. I Hear Banjos (Encore) has apple pie moonshine, rye, apple pie bitters, and cinnamon bark and applewood smoke—it tastes like a smoked apple pie and is reminiscent of being at a campfire in the woods."
Recipe:
1-1/4oz apple pie moonshine (unaged corn whiskey cut with apple juice and infused with cinnamon)
1-1/4oz Old Overholt Rye
2 dashes spiced apple bitters
Garnished with cinnamon bark and applewood smoke capped over the drink.
Wildest Redhead
Created by: Meaghan Dorman at
Lantern's Keep
"I came across a drink called a Wild Redhead in Stan Jones'
Barguidewhile perusing for drink inspirations. As a redhead, I was totally disappointed by the brilliant name and boring mix (equal parts lemon juice and Cherry Heering). A few weeks later when I was working on making an original Scotch cocktail for the opening list at Lantern's Keep I revisited the Wild Redhead and decided to update it to the Wildest Redhead—more complex and a whole lot boozier. This drink is available at both Lantern's Keep and Raines Law Room."
Recipe:
1.5oz blended Scotch
.75oz fresh lemon juice
.5oz honey syrup (3:1 honey to hot water)
.25oz all-spice dram
.25oz Cherry Heering
Add first 4 ingredients together in cocktail shaker and shake with ice. Pour over one big rock (preferably) in a double old-fashioned glass. Drizzle Cherry Heering over ice (creates a red fade effect).
The John Lee Hooker
Created by: Greg Seider at
Summit Bar
"Walking to work I was listening to the song ["One Bourbon, One Scotch, One Beer" by John Lee Hooker]. And I thought,
How can I possibly combine all those ingredients in the same cocktail and make it taste damn good? So you must the beer glass with Peat Monster scotch. Mix Buffalo Trace bourbon, cinnamon agave, fresh lemon juice, sarsaparilla bitters. Shake it up. Strain it over Ice and top with [Lagunitas] Hop Stoopid Double IPA beer. Boom... Boom Boom. Boom."
Recipe:
2oz buffalo trace
1oz Vietnamese cinnamon agave
.5oz lemon juice
2 dashes sarsaparilla bitters
1 dash orange bitters
Shake all ingredients in shaker. Strain into Scotch misted pilsner glass over ice. Top with IPA. Orange twist.
Laurel & Hardy
Created by: Tristan Willey, Bar Manager and Head Bartender at
Booker and Dax
“When creating this recipe, which relies heavily on very precise measurements to keep it balanced, we needed a way to describe the unique pours. When we added the Fernet Branca, we needed just a hair more than a quarter ounce so we called the measurement a 'fat' quarter. When measuring out the Luxardo Maraschino, we needed a hair under a half ounce so we called it a ‘skinny’ half. Since the measurements were funny and referenced skinny and fat as a duo, we named the drink the Laurel & Hardy after the comedic duo.”
Recipe:
8 drops of Bittermens Xocolatl Mole Bitters
2 barspoons of Benedictine
Fat 1/4oz Fernet Branca
Skinny 1/2oz Luxardo Maraschino
3/4oz Louis Royer Cognac
1.25oz Rittenhouse Rye Whiskey
Stir, strain, and serve in a coupe, no garnish.
Any Major Dude Will Tell You
Created by: Garret Smith at
Vinegar Hill House
"The name comes from a Steely Dan song about keeping faith and losing worry in the midst of a hard time, and we hope this cocktail might help someone toward that light just like the
song, which kind of tells it all."
Recipe:
2 and 1/4oz Laird's Bonded Applejack
2/3oz lemon juice
1/2oz honey syrup
1/4oz Saint Elizabeth's Allspice Dram
Behind God's Back
Created by: Jason Littrell at Death & Company
"'Behind God's Back' is a phrase that implies something either secret, or something that happens on the other side of the island."
Recipe:
.25oz orgeat
.25oz cinnamon syrup
.25oz cane syrup
.5oz pineapple juice
.75oz lime juice
2oz Chairman's Reserve St. Lucian Rum.
Swizzle ingredients in crushed ice, top with Angostura and Peychaud's bitters, and garnish with fresh mint.
I'll Have Another
Created by: Caitlin Doonan, Manager at
Má Pêche
“This cocktail is inspired by a mint julep, the drink closely associated with the Kentucky Derby. The name of the drink is the name of the winning horse in 2012. It also works well as a cocktail name because the drink is light and refreshing, and it's very easy to ‘have another
.'"
Recipe:
.5oz Cynar
.75oz Demerara Syrup (it's simple syrup made with demerara sugar)
2oz Rittenhouse Rye
Dash of Fee Brothers mint bitters
4-8 mint leaves
Stir, strain, and serve on crushed ice in a double old-fashioned glass. Garnish with mint leaves.
Doctor Johann
Created by: Chad Walsh at
The Dutch
"I was working on a drink with Blanco Tequila, different orange liqueurs (we occasionally sub in Mandarine Napoleon or Royal Combier, but the Shrubb's spiciness is perfect), and a ton of Angostura, which is such a delicious and often misunderstood product. It was foamy at first, and then it was a long drink (over crushed ice and topped with soda), but it wasn't until this version that I felt like it was expressing the essence of Angostura in the way I had been hoping for all along. It's named after the guy who invented Angostura, who was the surgeon general of Simón de Bolívar's army. The cocktail has more Ango in it (8 dashes) than I've ever put in a drink."
Recipe:
1oz Partida Blanco
1oz Rhum Clement Creole Shrub
1/2oz lime juice
8 dashes Angostura bitters
2 dashes Regan's Orange Bitters