Shared posts

12 Sep 05:45

A 21-year-old programmer sends legal notice to HP for "compelling" him to buy bundled OS

By Asha Menon

BANGALORE: A 21-year-old free-software enthusiast in Mumbai is taking on Hewlett-Packard, the multinational computer giant. Ishan Ketan Masdekar has sent a legal notice to HP for "compelling" him to buy a product that he says doesn't meet his requirements. The product in this case is Microsoft Windows 8 operating system, which came bundled with the HP Notebook he bought in June this year.

Masdekar's notice asks for a refund of his cost on the OS but, more importantly, he wants a change in HP's software terms policy, which the notice says is anti-competitive and violates India's Competition Act 2002.
Ishan Masdekar sends legal notice to HP for "compelling" him to buy a notebook with Windows 8The programmer at Digital Freedom Foundation is perhaps the first in India to send a notice to an original equipment manufacturer for bundling software with hardware, but he is part of a global trend. Free-software enthusiasts across the world run campaigns like 'No More Racketware' and fight what they call "Windows Tax".

In 2011, an Italian consumer watchdog took Microsoft to court over software bundling after it won a pilot case against HP in 2007 and, in 2012, a French buyer won a case against Lenovo. Microsoft has been fighting bundling accusations since the browser wars of the 1990s between Internet Explorer and Netscape. Masdekar himself has sent the notice not so much for the refund, but to make buyers aware that they have a choice.

"I don't care much for the refund," he said, "which would come to around Rs 3,000. I want people to know that they don't have to take whatever software is given to them."

Responding to ET's request for comment, HP said it "has an extensive product portfolio which provides consumers with variety, including units bundled with a built-in OS and those without".

Proprietary software makers and OEMs have their defence against the free-software activists. They say 'naked' PCs - machines that don't come with pre-installed OS - encourage piracy. Without the pre-installed OS, a user might be easily persuaded to buy a cheaper copy. Also a large portion of Indian consumers may not be looking for a choice, says Vishal Tripathi, principal research analyst at Gartner.

"Many buy PCs for their convenience and not to begin a learning curve (which an alternative OS would require)," he says. Therefore, a large number may prefer machines with pre-installed OS.

Windows' licence agreement leaves the resolution of conflicts such as Masdekar's to the laptop manufacturer's policy, in this case HP's. When Masdekar contacted HP's Customer Relations, a manager wrote back saying that "the HP OS Image (HP Recovery) is a bundled software meant for HP systems only" and a refund for the Windows 8 OS alone would not be possible.

Therefore the user, Masdekar, is now left with two options - use a software he does not want or return a hardware that he does. This does not mean that consumers have a choice of picking every model with or without OS, says Pravin A, founder of Pirate Movement of India. "Entry level, low-powered PCs usually come without an OS pre-installed."

Copyright © 2014 Times Internet Limited. All rights reserved.

05 Sep 06:34

Comic for September 4, 2014

30 Aug 13:21

Sssh! We’re celebrating our mother tongue day in Telugu.



Sssh! We’re celebrating our mother tongue day in Telugu.

28 Aug 12:55

Facebook rolls out 'bandwidth targeting' for advertisers

NEW DELHI: Social networking giant Facebook has rolled out a new "bandwidth targeting" feature globally for advertisers to help them reach people based on the type of network.

The move is especially relevant in emerging countries like India, where limited data plans and feature phones are common.

"Targeting by mobile network type helps advertisers choose creative that will run smoothly on any given device and connection speed.

"That is why we are launching a new feature that enables advertisers to reach people based on the network connection -- 2G, 3G or 4G -- they most often use when accessing Facebook," the social media giant said in a blogpost.

The US-based firm, which has over 1.32 billion users globally, already offers advertisers to reach people based on the type of device they use (smartphones, feature phones and tablets) as well as device model and operating system.

In June this year, Facebook COO Sheryl Sandberg had said 30 million small and medium businesses (SMBs) globally are using Facebook to connect to customers and expand their presence and reach.

India, which is Facebook's second largest market in terms of user-base, has nine lakh SMBs leveraging its platform.

"People want fast, efficient experiences on their phones. Our hope is that mobile network targeting can improve the experience people have with Facebook ads by helping advertisers deliver the right experience while respecting people's device bandwidth and data costs," Facebook Product Marketing Manager Brendan Sullivan said.

Advertisers like Vodafone in India are already testing these new targeting capabilities with good early results.

"We are excited about the new mobile targeting option on Facebook which allows us sharper targeting to a relevant audience," Vodafone India Senior Vice President (Brand Communication, Insights and Online) Ronita Mitra said.

Copyright © 2014 Times Internet Limited. All rights reserved.

20 Aug 08:59

The Batman Mythos

by geetanjali

batsupPublished on 3rd August, 2014 in The Speaking Tree

Seventy-five years ago, a hero was created in North America. His name was Batman. His real name was Bruce Wayne, a playboy millionaire, who as a child witnessed the murder of his parents by gangsters in a street alley and swore to cleanse his city of all crime. He prepared himself by becoming a martial arts expert and by creating numerous scientific gadgets especially the bat-mobile, a car that can turn into a bike, a submarine, and even a plane. He also created a costume for himself that enabled him to fly and most importantly hide his identity. Like a bat, he appeared only in the night and spent the day preparing in his laboratory and hideout, the bat cave. Born in the 1939, the hero continues to have a vast fan following, not because crime continues to infest his mythical Gotham city, but because he has been reinvented several times in comic books, in animation films, in television series and Hollywood films.

1939 marks the start of the Second World War. The years before that marked the Great Depression, a global economic slump, rise in bootlegging due to prohibition and the consequent rise in organised crime in the cities of North America. To bring hope to the Americans, Action Comics introduced the world’s first superhero called Superman in 1938, who was dressed in red and blue (the colours of the American flag), who was clean shaven, represented all that was good and great about America, and most important was an immigrant, taking shelter from another planet, Krypton. He was a man of steel, stronger than anyone, capable of flight and X-ray vision. And he fought evil scientists like Lex Luthor and Braniac, while pretending to be a simple lovable reporter called Clark Kent. The success of Superman led to the creation of Batman by Detective Comics of National Publications (later DC comics).

Batman was different. He was not from another planet. He did not have superpowers. He was a victim of gangster crime. He was not a farm boy; he was rich and brilliant. While Superman’s enemies were evil geniuses who used brainpower, Batman was a genius himself inventing various crime fighting tools like the batmobile, the batplane, the characteristic multi-purpose utility belt and the boomerang-like batarang. Then there was the bat-signal that could be flashed across the night sky by the Gotham Police Department to inform Batman that he was needed, just as tolling church bells informed angels in heaven they were needed to save the faithful from the forces of evil. He imitated bats, but unlike Count Dracula who could turn himself into a bat, he was a tortured saviour, not a minion of the Devil.

In the early years, Batman did not agonize over killing criminals. He did all his fighting alone like a lone ranger. In the post-war period, the dark decaying city of Gotham was replaced by bright cheerfulness to create positive reinforcement amongst children growing up in a new world order. Violence was toned down and when it appeared it was full of funny onscreen captions that said: “Sock!”, “Pow!” and “Wham!” There was no more use of gun or display of killing. The macho pulp style was softened by the introduction of a young sidekick called Robin dressed in red and green, who joined him in his adventures. He was created because just as Sherlock Holmes had a Watson, Batman needed someone to talk to.

In the 1970s, Batman and Robin were part of a popular television series that was high on ‘camp’ – a style that is over-the-top, gaudy and tongue-in-cheek. The costume and music evoked laughter. And it led to speculations that Batman was gay, and probably in a relationship with Robin. These speculations turned to accusations that young children were being corrupted by such underlying homoerotic themes. The publishers and the fans were not amused. Robin was killed, and all efforts were made to show Batman did love girls by introducing female sidekicks and Batgirl and Batwoman. But the subtext persists.

Hollywood films transformed Batman dramatically. He became a brooding vigilante. He was not just the World’s Greatest Detective; he was now Dark Knight and Caped Crusader. One cannot escape the use of medieval and biblical descriptions. His scowl was contrasted by the sneer of his greatest enemy, Joker, with a false smile. His monastic lonesome stance was contrasted by the very sexual Catwoman whose clothing evoked sado-masochistic sexual imagery, and Poison Ivy, the eco-terrorist whose kiss is poisonous. In contrast to very sexy female foes, the male foes were typically ugly as we see in case Penguin and Two-Face, leading to observations related to sexism and internalised homophobia. His body suit in the films was now sculpted so that he looked like the perfect macho Greek hero, a far cry from the campy tights of the 1970s shows. And yes, the films– except the 1997 Batman & Robin that tried unsuccessfully to go back to the old campy style – give a lot of importance to Batman’s tortured and tragic romantic relationships with women.

The transformation of Batman from pulp hero who fought gangsters, to campy hero with a sidekick called Robin, to the Dark Knight, reflects change in American society. That Gotham is always dark and grey, constantly on the brink of a terrible crisis, makes one wonder the American worldview with its obsession for vigilante form of justice belying its lack of faith in the justice system. Something Batman needs to think about on his seventy-fifth birthday.

20 Aug 08:59

What Is ‘Indianisation’ Of Education?

by geetanjali

elusiveownershipPublished on 10th August, 2014, in The Speaking Tree

What should we teach our children: Mahavira’s birth date, or that he was the last of the 24 great pathfinders born in every cycle of the universe, or his philosophy of multiple truths? The date of Buddha’s death or that his previous lives are recorded in the Jataka Tales or his doctrine that showed the way out of suffering? The geographical location of the Kurukshetra War or stories of Ravana’s flying chariot that brought Rama back to Ayodhya or the nature of the world based on rebirth described in the Bhagwad Gita? The spot where Jesus was crucified or the story of the immaculate conception of Jesus or the parables through which he revealed God’s unconditional love? The dispute over succession between Prophet Muhammad’s father-in-law and son-in-law, the story of how he travelled from Mecca to Jerusalem to the Seventh Heaven on a great winged horse or the code of conduct he presented to the world?

What we choose to teach our children reveals our prejudices and our hierarchies: it shows us up – what we consider to be true and worthy knowledge and what we dismiss as irrelevant and false – whether we are parochial, global or cosmic in outlook.

History gives us objective truth about the past based on data: archaeology, epigraphy, archaeology, and contemporary records. How the data-points are joined to create a pattern remains speculative, rooted on the political leanings of the historian. For example, some historians qualify events of 1857 as an Uprising, others as Mutiny, but no one disputes the data that numerous battles were fought between various groups of Indians and the East India Company that sought political control in the subcontinent.

Mythology gives us subjective truth of a people through their stories, symbols and rituals; by its very nature it is indifferent to rationality. Every tribe, community, and religion has its own version of reality. For some the perfect world was created in six days before God decided to rest. For others the Creator emerges from the lotus that rises from the navel of the preserver who sleeps on the coils of a serpent that floats on an infinite ocean.

In the Nehruvian era, we were taught to value history and cultivate scientific temper, outgrowing religion and mythology. We inherited the colonial attitude of qualifying mythology as ‘false knowledge of the uneducated’. We overlooked the fact that the colonisers never treated their own Biblical mythology as falsehood. In our quest to be secular we turned indifferent, even hostile, to people’s faiths. Hindu customs and beliefs were especially at the receiving end for various political reasons.

Today scholars are recognising how beneath the veneer of secular rationality wars across the world, such as the ongoing conflict in Gaza, can be traced to mythologies of the Chosen People and the Promised Land and medieval crusades. Post-modern scholars and psychologists are talking about the value of subjective truths and personal and cultural narratives to navigate our way through life. In other words, people are realising mythology is not ‘falsehood’ but personal and communal truths, critical for human survival.

We need to stop emulating archaic mindsets that sought to overthrow ‘false’ gods with ‘true’ gods. Let’s teach children to recognise that human lives are shaped by both objective and subjective truths, not all Hindu. We have to move from vi-vaad or argument, where we only seek to prove others wrong, to sam-vaad or discussion, where we learn to appreciate why others cling to a truth so different than ours.

21 Jul 11:35

Do You Really Need 4 GB of RAM to Type a Letter?

by Charles Murray
The recent decision by the German parliament to consider a move back to typewriters may serve as a lesson, not only in the need for secure products, but also in the dangers of overdesign.
07 Jul 06:39

The Pinnacle of Human Communication

by Abi

Yo!

I needed this to figure it out: 9 Questions about 'Yo' You were Embarrassed to Ask.

* * *

Hat tip to Joshua Gans whose post examines the informational content Yo.

04 Jul 12:33

Comic for July 4, 2014

03 Jul 05:22

become

by Lunarbaboon

02 Jul 09:32

Identity politics in secularism’s name

ET Bureau Jun 30, 2014, 04.00AM IST

(The Congress is being identified…)

AK Antony should be wary of Harsh Vardhan, the Union minister against vulgarity, when he plays the role of the little boy who calls the bluff on the emperor's new clothes.

The Congress, said Antony recently, is being identified as a pro-minority party in a way that antagonises the majority and this would help the growth of communal forces.

This should be the beginning of an important piece of deconstruction — of the notion of secularism as practised by the Congress. Only by affirming secularism in the sense in which it finds a place in the Constitution can the Congress hope to regain lost ground and help the larger polity keep majoritarianism at bay.

Secularism in the classical sense means separation of religion from the state. In India, it has come to mean equal treatment of all religions by the state rather than denial of any room in the public sphere for religion.

However, the way the Congress has practised secularism, it has come to mean playing identity politics with Muslim sentiments. When the Sachar committee report came up with the finding that Muslims were exceptionally deprived in most states of the country, the UPA government declared that the minorities would have the first claim on the nation's resources.

In practice, the minorities continued to be deprived, Muslim youths got picked up, particularly in Congressruled Maharashtra, and implicated in terror cases on the flimsiest of evidence, only to be released years later. This has served to antagonise both Hindus and Muslims and also to give secularism itself a bad name, as a disingenuous term for minority identity politics.

To reclaim secularism and redeem itself, the Congress needs to appreciate the good sense in what Antony says. It has not, at least in Maharashtra, where chief minister Prithviraj Chavan seeks to buy votes with quotas. Community-based mobilisation in itself does not constitute communalism.

But such mobilisation in hostility to another community is communalism. Tolerance of minority communalism is fodder for majority communalism and secular parties must appreciate this reality as well.

02 Jul 06:17

Comic for June 27, 2014

02 Jul 06:12

A Little Kindness

by DOGHOUSE DIARIES

A Little Kindness

It gets awkward fast.

02 Jul 05:12

Facebook manipulated users emotions in secret study: Report

WASHINGTON: A study detailing how Facebook secretly manipulated the news feed of some 700,000 users to study "emotional contagion" has prompted anger on social media. For one week in 2012 Facebook tampered with the algorithm used to place posts into user news feeds to study how this affected their mood.

The study, conducted by researchers affiliated with Facebook, Cornell University, and the University of California at San Francisco, appeared in the June 17 edition of the Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences.

The researchers wanted to see if the number of positive, or negative, words in messages they read affected whether users then posted positive or negative content in their status updates. Indeed, after the exposure the manipulated users began to use negative or positive words in their updates depending on what they were exposed to. Results of the study spread when the online magazine Slate and The Atlantic website wrote about it on Saturday.

"Emotional states can be transferred to others via emotional contagion, leading people to experience the same emotions without their awareness," the study authors wrote. "These results indicate that emotions expressed by others on Facebook influence our own emotions, constituting experimental evidence for massive-scale contagion via social networks."

While other studies have used metadata to study trends, this appears to be unique because it manipulates the data to see if there is a reaction.

The study was legal according to Facebook's rules -- but was it ethical? "#Facebook MANIPULATED USER FEEDS FOR MASSIVE PSYCH EXPERIMENT... Yeah, time to close FB acct!" read one Twitter posting. Other tweets used words like "super disturbing," "creepy" and "evil," as well as angry expletives, to describe the experiment.

Susan Fiske, a Princeton University professor who edited the report for publication, told The Atlantic that she was concerned about the research and contacted the authors. They in turn said that their institutional review boards approved the research "on the grounds that Facebook apparently manipulates people's News Feeds all the time".

Fiske admitted to being "a little creeped out" by the study. Facebook told The Atlantic that they "carefully consider" their research, and have "a strong internal review process". Facebook, the world's biggest social network, says it has more than one billion active users.

Copyright © 2014 Times Internet Limited. All rights reserved.

23 Jun 08:34

Need a loan? P2P portals can help you borrow at lower rates

You need to borrow Rs 1 lakh urgently. A bank would charge you 18-24% depending on your credit history and repayment capacity. At the same time, someone in another part of the country wants to invest Rs 1 lakh in a safe avenue. A bank deposit will yield around 9-10% a year but he's looking for a better deal without any risk. Wouldn't it be great if you could meet that person and offer him 12% on his money? After he checks your income details and repayment record, he might agree to lend that Rs 1 lakh to you.

Till now, finding that individual was like searching for a needle in a haystack. But a clutch of companies is bringing prospective lenders and borrowers together. You can register online and meet people who are willing to lend or borrow from you. "We are an e-Bay for loans," says Rajat Gandhi, CEO of Gugaon-based Faircent, which began operations last year and has already disbursed loans to 123 borrowers.

Though individuals have been lending to each other since time immemorial, this segment of credit has been largely unorganized. Without any proper paperwork, people only lent to business associates, friends or relatives. But companies like Faircent and the Hyderabad-based i-Lend have turned this traditional funding mechanism into an organised market.

In the process, they have reduced the spread between the lending and deposit rates of banks. It's a win-win arrangement, which lets investors earn higher returns on their capital at low risk, and borrowers get access to funds at lower rates. For example, a bank charges roughly 20-24% for an unsecured loan but offers barely 9-10% on fixed deposits. The difference (also known as the spread) is pocketed by the bank. "Our innovative model not only removes the complexity of modern banking, but also cuts the spread and passes on the savings to depositors and borrowers," says Gandhi.

How can you get a loan through these P2P portals? For one, you must have an impeccable repayment record. VVSSB Shankar, founder and director of i-Lend, says only credible borrowers are introduced to the investors. Investors prefer borrowers who are educated, have a steady job and have a good credit history. A high credit score will automatically help you get a loan faster and at compratively lower rates.

How safe is it to lend to a complete stranger whom you have never met and won't even see? The peer-to-peer companies insist that it is very safe. Shankar says the annual default rate is a mere 3-4%. "We have never had a full default till now," he adds. Gandhi says they screen borrowers diligently. "We follow the same process as any bank before a borrower is allowed to list on the Faircent site," he says.

To reduce the risk further, the P2P portals advise lenders to diversify their lending across 4-5 different borrowers, though oneto-one deals are also allowed. Shankar cites the example of a lender who spread his investment of Rs 1 lakh across five loans of Rs 20,000 each.

Copyright © 2014 Times Internet Limited. All rights reserved.

21 Jun 05:40

Trainman Predicts Your chances of Train Ticket Confirmation

by Manish Singh

Booking a railway ticket — both online and via standing in elongated queues is a traumatic experience in India. Furthermore, there is no surety that your ticket, if it is in waiting list will ever get confirmed.

An online service called Trainman might be able to help you with that. Trainman is able to predict how likely it is that your ticket will get a secured berth.

1

A website which loads pretty fast, Trainman doesn’t require any signup. You can mention the train you wish to board, the class you would like to travel, the date of your journey, kinda like IRCTC. Once you are done filling the required information, in addition to the list of trains available on your route, you also get to check your confirmation chances, and recent trends.

The ‘confirmation chances’ tells you how likely it is that you will get the ticket. The service says that anything above 65% holds a good chance. To make it even more useful for the users, the service uses color coding. Anything in green is good, whereas you might want to bunk the present option and look for alternative if the percentile is in yellow.

The prediction is based on past learning. The service claims that is has tested over 100,000 PNRs, out of which it has succeeded around 80-90 percent of the time.

In my brief testing, I found the results very reliable. And as a person who has to book tickets every few days, I think this service will be very useful to me, and hopefully, you as well. You will also find our curated list of online services, apps and travel hacks to enhance your commute experience useful.

The post Trainman Predicts Your chances of Train Ticket Confirmation appeared first on NextBigWhat.

19 Jun 09:02

Aam Aadmi Party: Stick with internal democracy, transparency

ET Bureau Jun 9, 2014, 05.29AM IST

(The way AAP went about garnering…)

It would be easy to label the top-level blame game within the Aam Aadmi Party (AAP) as a clash of personalities. But the problem is deeper, more to do with the lack of an established structure.

Complaints of a personality cult and lack of democratic functioning have come up in public bickering between leaders Manish Sisodia and Yogendra Yadav over the party's debacle in the Lok Sabha polls. It would also be easy to dismiss all this as evidence of a party's overreach, of an organisation that did surprisingly well in Delhi's assembly polls, shook up the established players, but then whose over-vaulting ambition led it astray.

This theory would have it that AAP is yet a party in the making. That may be the case, but it is also important to remember that AAP did a laudable job of acting on the promise of a new era of transparency in politics, and our polity has much to benefit from the party self-correcting and re-establishing itself.

The way AAP went about garnering funds pretty much broke the mould of Indian politics, where unaccounted funding and spending by parties remains one of the main causes of corruption in public life. That the party spread itself too thin, overestimated its own appeal nationally, might be true. Taking on the might of established players would take some doing.

Despite that, the party must stick to its transparent methods of funding, even raise the pitch on this count so that the BJP and Congress are forced to take some action on that front.

In tandem, the absence of democratic functioning within the party must be made good and, that done, gains like the four seats in Punjab it got can be built on. For, it is still possible that the party can gain in areas where the established players are perceived as not having been able to deliver. But, as of now, the party seems about to implode.

The hasty decision to quit the Delhi government was a disaster, and much of the goodwill and positive buzz about the party seems to have evaporated. The task now is to pull itself up by the bootstraps, focus on areas where it can put up a fight, and gear up for a long haul.

19 Jun 09:02

Nokia India implements 'Bridge' programme to help former employees of Chennai plant

CHENNAI: Nokia India is implementing what it calls a 'Bridge' programme for former employees who lost their jobs, providing vital help during a difficult period and earning goodwill among those who worked at its Chennai plant.

The Finnish mobile phone maker's India manufacturing unit was at one time a marquee investment and a symbol of India's importance for Nokia. But the company quickly fell into troubled times. It has shed thousands of jobs at the Chennai factory but in a rare example of corporate social responsibility, it is trying to help its former employees cope with their reversal in fortunes.
Among those benefitting is K Thyagarajan, 27, a former Nokia India worker who like most others suddenly lost his job and was clueless about what he would do next. He had opted for the voluntary retirement scheme and the exit had left him at a crossroads. "We were like a family, nearly 7,000 employees at the factory. I was extremely sad when they announced the VRS," said Thyagarajan. And just as he was trying to recover from the job loss, he received a letter from Nokia India requesting him to attend some interactive sessions. Thyagarajan initially ignored the letter, but then decided to give in to the persuasion.

Thyagarajan became a part of Nokia's Bridge programme, which conducts awareness and training sessions for employees to help them secure a new job or start a new venture. It is aimed at those who have worked with the company for at least five years. Apart from structured financial assistance, the programme offers beauty treatment courses, MS Office/Tally accounting courses, training for commissioning of solar units, desktop publishing modules and garment-making. In all, there are about 30 modules being conducted in around 40 locations in TN.

According to company statistics, over 60% of the outgoing employees have attended the awareness sessions and almost all have opted for the training sessions that have commenced in a few centres.

Ajit Isaac, the chairman and managing director of Ikya Human Capital Solutions, said that initiatives such as these help employees gain new skills and provide them the confidence to seek opportunities outside. Industry experts are of the view that helping employees to get another job in a difficult situation is new in the Indian context whereas globally many organisations do so. "These programmes would be based on the opportunities available in the market. This is a welcome move. Any corporate which does this, they have the long-term interests of their employees in mind," said K Purushothaman, a regional director of software industry grouping Nasscom.

Nokia's factory was excluded from a Microsoft's recent acquisition of Nokia's devices and services units. The Chennai plant was left out of the deal because it is entangled in a legal dispute with tax authorities in New Delhi and Chennai, and the assets of this division has been frozen as a result of the dispute.

The factory, located at Sriperumbudur, about 40 km from Chennai, is now operating as a contract manufacturer for Microsoft. Although the timeframe of this arrangement with Microsoft is unclear, Nokia India began cutting its workforce by announcing an early retirement scheme. A month after concluding the VRS programme, Nokia India came up with the Bridge programme. It has tied up with TVS Training and Services and Ace Skill Development to design and implement the programme.

A Nokia India spokeswoman says the company has invested "tens of millions of euros" to run the Bridge program globally in which around 18,000 employees have participated. She claims the program has been successful where it "has resulted in the creation of 1,000 new companies across 19 cities/sites worldwide" and "more than 90% of those companies are still active".

The company declined to provide specific information on investments in the programme in India.

P Chitra, 27, who worked at Nokia India's factory for eight years, has now registered a partnership firm with other four ex-employees to export fancy jewellery. The group of five was already pursuing this as a hobby before deciding to take it up as a full-time business opportunity. The initial investment for the business came from the Bridge compensation and the VRS amounts of these five former Nokia employees.

"We are aiming to earn a profit of Rs 1 lakh per person per month," said a confident Chitra.

Copyright © 2014 Times Internet Limited. All rights reserved.

17 Jun 06:43

Tesla Cars, Space Technology, and BitTorrent: Why Monopolies Suck

by Rick Falkvinge

copyright-brandedWhen Bram Cohen created the BitTorrent protocol, he had the legal option of filing for a patent monopoly on any computer program that used this protocol. (The mere existence of such an option is a very bad thing, but we’ll be returning to that.) Mr. Cohen chose to not monopolize the BitTorrent protocol in that way. Let’s examine what implications that would have had for the technology.

If the BitTorrent technology would have been protected by patent monopolies, it would have been effectively limited to Mr. Cohen’s original BitTorrent client. Have you used that client? Do you know anybody who has used it? Didn’t think so, and neither do I. Instead, there is an enormous plethora of clients and servers that use the protocol today, and Mr. Cohen’s BitTorrent Inc. is valued at eight-digit dollars. Not to mention the fact that BitTorrent Inc. was subsequently able to buy one of the most prolific BitTorrent clients out there, µTorrent, which would not have existed had the technology been monopolized in the first place. I think most of us have used µTorrent – I know I have.

This shows exactly why it makes so much sense for Tesla Cars to release all of their patent monopolies into the wild, and why the patent monopoly system as such is enormously harmful (the only industry to make a net profit from it is the pharma industry, and that’s because they’re heavily subsidized with taxpayer money). Tesla Cars relinquishing their monopolies means they see this mechanism, and that they realize they need an ecosystem to flourish around their technology – the electric car technology – in order to remain viable themselves. Put another way, it’s not about the size of the pie slice: monopolies are preventing the pie itself from growing exponentially, as they do with any new technology poised to disrupt the old ways.

Just like BitTorrent.

Patent monopolies are far worse than the copyright monopolies we deal with (and all break) on a daily basis. Imagine for a moment if copyright monopoly vultures didn’t care if you had made an actual copy, that you would be just as guilty of infringement even if you had never seen or heard of the original? That’s how patent monopolies work, and that’s the key difference between patent monopolies and copyright monopolies: the latter protect a specific expression against copying, the former protect an idea or a form from being utilized anywhere, even independently. It’s also why patent monopolies are much, much more harmful than copyright monopolies (and that’s saying a lot).

But as the Tesla example shows, patent monopolies don’t stop at not making sense as a whole. They also don’t make sense to a single company in isolation, as they prevent an ecosystem taking shape. It’s one of the worst cancers in the economy, as investors describe them today.

It’s easy to argue that patent monopolies don’t hit ordinary families in the same way that copyright monopolies, that patent monopolies have not sued families out of their homes merely for taking part in society’s culture. But that’s about to change with 3D printing, where rapid fabrication becomes available to the masses. It is – unfortunately – a safe prediction that people will soon be sued out of their homes merely for manufacturing their own pair of slippers, because it violated a design patent monopoly somewhere. Such a notion may seem ridiculous today. Then again, so did everything else we’ve seen with the copyright monopoly so far, and patent monopolies are guarded far more harshly.

The BitTorrent legacy doesn’t just show us how to break the copyright monopoly in a specific case. It gives us a blueprint for how to disrupt old ways in general by ditching legal monopolies, a blueprint that Tesla Cars is now choosing to follow.

The patent monopoly wars are coming, right on the heels of the copyright monopoly wars, as were they merely a logical extension. That’s why it’s so encouraging to see our tip-of-the-spear entrepreneurs denouncing and releasing their own monopolies right ahead of these battles with corporate lawyers.

As a final note, it’s noteworthy that Tesla Cars isn’t the only company that Elon Musk is running. He’s also at the helm of SpaceX. Space technology has been ridiculously proprietary up until now, nothing cooperating with anything else and everything being custom-built single-use. That’s why it makes me enormously excited to see an entrepreneur who understands the damages of monopolies at the forefront of space technology today.

It holds a promise of standardized, interoperable space technology. As in, “for all of us”. Like BitTorrent.

About The Author

Rick Falkvinge is a regular columnist on TorrentFreak, sharing his thoughts every other week. He is the founder of the Swedish and first Pirate Party, a whisky aficionado, and a low-altitude motorcycle pilot. His blog at falkvinge.net focuses on information policy.

Book Falkvinge as speaker?

Follow @Falkvinge

Source: TorrentFreak, for the latest info on copyright, file-sharing and anonymous VPN services.

16 Jun 06:32

Comic for June 9, 2014

16 Jun 06:29

Comic for June 13, 2014

07 Jun 17:14

Internet giants like Google making it difficult for NSA & spy agencies to pierce their systems

By David E. Sanger and Nicole Perlroth

MOUNTAIN VIEW (CALIFORNIA): Just down the road from Google's main campus here, engineers for the company are accelerating what has become the newest arms race in modern technology: They are making it far more difficult - and far more expensive - for the National Security Agency and the intelligence arms of other governments around the world to pierce their systems.

As fast as it can, Google is sealing up cracks in its systems that Edward J. Snowden revealed the NSA had brilliantly exploited. It is encrypting more data as it moves among its servers and helping customers encode their own emails. Facebook, Microsoft and Yahoo are taking similar steps.

After years of cooperating with the government, the immediate goal is to thwart Washington - as well as Beijing and Moscow. The strategy is also intended to preserve business overseas in places like Brazil and Germany that have threatened to entrust data only to local providers.

Google, for example, is laying its own fiber optic cable under the world's oceans, a project that began as an effort to cut costs and extend its influence but now has an added purpose: to assure that the company will have more control over the movement of its customers' data.

A year after Snowden's revelations, the era of quiet cooperation is over. Telecommunications companies say they are denying requests to volunteer data not covered by existing law. AT&T, Verizon and others say that compared with a year ago, they are far more reluctant to cooperate with the US government in "gray areas" where there is no explicit requirement for a legal warrant.

But governments are fighting back, harder than ever. Cellphone giant Vodafone reported Friday that a "small number" of governments around the world had demanded the ability to tap directly into its communication networks, a level of surveillance that elicited outrage from privacy advocates.

Vodafone refused to name the nations Friday for fear of putting its business and employees at risk there. But in an accounting of the number of legal demands for information that it receives, it noted that some countries did not issue warrants to obtain phone, email or web-searching traffic because "the relevant agencies and authorities already have permanent access to customer communications via their own direct link."

The company also said it had to acquiesce to some governments' requests for data to comply with national laws. Otherwise, it said, it faced losing its license to operate in certain countries.

Eric Grosse, Google's security chief, suggested in an interview that the NSA's own behavior invited the new arms race.

"I am willing to help on the purely defensive side of things," he said, referring to Washington's efforts to enlist Silicon Valley in cybersecurity efforts. "But signals intercept is totally off the table," he said, referring to national intelligence gathering.

"No hard feelings, but my job is to make their job hard," he added.

Copyright © 2014 Times Internet Limited. All rights reserved.

30 May 11:46

What The…Pranav Mistry Pitches for a Job to NaMo; Is Samsung Listening?

by Jayadevan P K

Pranav MistryDear Samsung, we don’t have sixth sense. Hence the straight question: is Pranav Mistry quitting? It would appear that he just did (or soon will), in a very public manner.

It was surprising to read this morning that he is eager to join the newly formed Indian government to work with fellow Gujarati Narendra Modi who is now the Prime Minister of India.

“I am waiting for him to pop the question… and ready to say bye to my lab,” Mistry, a Modi admirer told a financial daily.

Wow, now thats just short of saying something like “I quit, this job is too boring. And I want to change the way the world works.”

Here’s his pitch: If I get to be here (in India), I see myself in a role of bringing change to lives of the masses, which is far more satisfying (than being an innovator per se!).

Sometimes I wonder, am I in the wrong field? I should try ________________.

— Pranav Mistry (@pranavmistry) May 20, 2014

What more, he already has a role on his mind: “I (am more suited to a role) as an advisor to the PM or to the science and technology ministry,” said Mistry who is planning to “call on” the Indian Prime Minister in June. Hopefully, on his Samsung phone.

Unless there’s more to the story, this is sort of a cold call to NaMo. May not be all that high on professionalism. Nevertheless, this is a big deal, if you read it with the fact that scientists have been quitting India for a long time now. And we sure have a serious innovation problem to solve.

Good for us, if this is the beginning of a new trend.

Read : When the world trolled Pranav Mistry’s Gujju accent]

The post What The…Pranav Mistry Pitches for a Job to NaMo; Is Samsung Listening? appeared first on NextBigWhat.

30 May 06:25

Arrest of Amway CEO: Multi-level political test for PM Narendra Modi

The arrest of Amway India CEO William S Pinckney from the company headquarters in Gurgaon by Kurnool police is deeply troubling. It calls for a systemic solution apart from immediate relief for the harassed executive, for whom this is the second taste of legal high-handedness. Should a complaint against a company lead to arrest of its CEO and his incarceration?

Are there no ways to investigate a case like this without putting the CEO in jail? Is the cost to any aggrieved consumer, whose complaint leads to the arrest, greater than the reputational damage to India as an investment destination? Based as it is on a state-level law, the arrest presents itself as a challenge to the new prime minister, one reflecting the complexity of improving things in our multi-level polity.

Amway's business model is direct selling using multilevel marketing, in which an operative who recruits new operatives gets a commission from the sale proceeds of his recruits and of their recruits down the chain of recruitment. It is easy to confuse this with a pyramid/Ponzi scheme.

The crucial, distinction between legitimate multilevel marketing and a pyramid scheme is that mere recruitment will generate income for those up the chain in a pyramid scheme while only genuine sales by the recruits will generate incomes for those up the hierarchy in legitimate business.

In its initial phase, Amway India did use to count the kit supplied to a new recruit as a sale qualifying for a commission, creating an overlap with a pyramid scheme. But that is no longer the case and only real sales generate incomes. It should be possible for the police to establish this without actually arresting anyone. Narendra Modi is a champion of states' rights. But when state-level laws and practices damage India's collective interests, the Centre has the duty to countervail these offending laws and practices.

How this is done is a matter of political management, not of strong-arm tactics or federal trespass. That management is crucial, and state laws must align with a model, central law on multilevel marketing.

Copyright © 2014 Times Internet Limited. All rights reserved.

30 May 06:25

Really, Is the Rs 4000 cr Acquisition of Network18 by RIL about 4G Play?

by Jayadevan P K

Reliance LogoFirst the news: Reliance Industries is acquiring Network18 Media & Investments Limited for Rs 4,000 cr. Independent Media Trust, owned by Reliance, will acquire 78% in NW18 and 9% in TV18. This is easily one of the largest take overs in the Indian media business.

Reliance said in a press release earlier today that the acquisition will differentiate Reliance’s 4G business “by providing a unique amalgamation at the intersect of telecom, web and digital commerce via a suite of premier digital properties.”

Network18 owns In.com, IBNLive.com, Moneycontrol.com, Firstpost.com, Cricketnext.in, Homeshop18, Bookmyshow.com and broadcast channels including Colors, CNNIBN, CNBCTV18, IBN7 and CNBC Awaaz. As we’d pointed out, the digital content business hasn’t grown a whole lot in the last year.

Now we know that Reliance is dead serious about its 4G roll out. It has a whole suite of digital offerings lined up around the launch including music streaming, video calling, instant messaging and payment services.

We also know that content is set to explode with 4G connectivity. India’s appetite for smartphone and mobile data is also growing.  It is natural for the $67 bn group to not just control the pipe but also make money from the services that run on top of it (expect net neutrality debate to heat up soon). But really, a Rs 4000 cr acquisition to back its 4G play? Or is it payback time?  Network18 is had borrowed from RIL in 2012 for leveraged buyouts to expand its network earlier.  In 2012, through Independent Media Trust, RIL had invested in optionally convertible debentures from Network18′s promoter group. These can be converted to shares within 10 years from being issued (h/t: nixxin). RIL already paid for what it will now control.

What do you think?

The post Really, Is the Rs 4000 cr Acquisition of Network18 by RIL about 4G Play? appeared first on NextBigWhat.

30 May 06:24

Smriti Irani & Nripendra Misra: Controversies around 'eligibility' are pointless

ET Bureau May 30, 2014, 03.31AM IST

(If the people choose to place…)

The controversies over the choice of Smriti Irani as minister for human resources development and of former Telecom Regulatory Authority of India chairman Nripendra Misra as principal secretary to the prime minister are devoid of substance and a waste of time. Many people have tried to argue that a minimum level of certified education should be made an eligibility condition to be elected to a legislature. The framers of the Constitution rejected this argument for good reasons.

If the people choose to place their faith in someone, that is reason enough for him/her to qualify as a people's representative. Any such representative is eligible to hold higher office. Democratic accountability will ensure that a wrong choice is penalised, subsequently. Many leaders have built their political career dropping out of college. This does not make them any the less public-spirited or capable of upholding the larger public interest while taking policy decisions.

The job of a minister is not to have expertise in the area under his/her charge but to have a clear idea as to the public interest in that area and draw on expertise to attain that. The lack of educational qualification is, of course, altogether different from any misrepresentation of educational qualifications attained.

Such misconduct would have its own legal consequences. The purpose of barring subsequent employment for regulators is to guard against any favour being shown to a potential future employer. Such a provision is neither sufficient nor necessary to prevent regulatory capture. Continuous scrutiny of regulatory policy and action by the media and watchdog bodies is the best guarantee of propriety.

Misra's past membership of the regulatory body should not come in the way of the services of this upright, efficient officer being utilised further.

29 May 07:23

Apple adds more swagger with $3 billion Beats acquisition

CUPERTINO, CALIFORNIA: Apple is buying more flair, swagger and song-picking savvy with its $3 billion acquisition of Beats Electronics, a headphone and music streaming specialist founded by rapper Dr. Dre and Jimmy Iovine, one of the first recording executives to roll with the hip-hop culture.

Wednesday's announcement came nearly three weeks after deal negotiations were leaked to the media.

It's by far the most expensive acquisition in Apple's 38-year old history, a price that the company is paying to counter a threat posed to its iTunes store.

The price consists of $2.6 billion in cash and $400 million in Apple stock that will vest over an unspecified time period. The deal is expected to close before October.

With $1.1 billion in revenue last year, Beats is already making money and will boost Apple's earnings once the new fiscal year begins in October, Apple CEO Tim Cook said in an interview.

Iovine, 61, and Dre, 49, were the keys to the deal. They began working with Apple in the early days of its iTunes store and now will become key in Apple's music divisions, though Cook said their roles haven't been determined yet

"We have known these guys forever," Cook said of Iovine and Dre. "We've dated, we've gone steady and now we are getting married. This relationship started a decade ago, so we know there is an incredible cultural fit. These two guys have a very rare set of skills. It's like finding a particular grain of sand on the beach. It's that rare."

Cook indicated Beats' music streaming service was the main selling point in the deal, though the headphone line also is expected to continue growing, too.

Although he regards most technology companies as "culturally inept," Iovine believes Apple will empower Beats to realize its goals of improving the sound of digital music and creating playlists tailored for each subscriber.

"To complete our dream, we needed a company like (Apple)," Iovine said in an interview. "We couldn't finish this on our own."

The growing popularity of music streaming services such as Pandora and Spotify has been reducing sales of songs and albums, a business that iTunes has dominated for the past decade. U.S. sales of downloaded songs slipped 1 per cent last year to $2.8 billion while streaming music revenue surged 39 per cent to $1.4 billion, according to the Recording Industry Association of America.

Although Apple broke into streaming with the launch of iTunes Radio last September, the service has not been as popular or as lucrative as the company expected, according to two people familiar with the matter. The people were not authorized to speak publicly about the matter and spoke on condition of anonymity.

ITunes Radio has 40 million listeners and will continue as a free service with ads while Beats Music will try to tap into the more than 800 million iTunes accounts to sell more subscriptions to its customized service.

Beats Music currently has more than 250,000 subscribers, Cook said. That's well below the more than 10 million paying customers that Spotify's streaming service boasts.

Apple is counting on the Beats acquisition to boost its cachet with teenagers and younger adults as it tries to remain a leader in digital music - an industry that looks much different than when Apple reshaped the scene with the 2001 debut of the iPod.

"Apple suddenly has regained its cool," said Sony Music CEO Doug Morris, who was one of the first recording executives to embrace iTunes at Iovine's urging more than a decade ago.

Beats was founded in 2008 by Dr. Dre, whose real name is Andre Young, and Iovine, a longtime recording industry executive who is stepping down as chairman of Universal Music Group's Interscope Geffen A&M Records to join Apple. It now dominates the luxury headphone market. Its equipment is also a big seller in Apple's stores.

Operating from its Culver City, California, headquarters, Beats commands 62 per cent of the $1 billion U.S. market for headphones priced above $100, according to NPD Group.

The purchase marks Apple CEO Tim Cook's biggest strategic break from the way the Cupertino, California, company was led under co-founder Steve Jobs, who died in October 2011. Jobs favored smaller acquisitions and didn't believe subscription music plans would be popular.

Before Beats, Apple's biggest acquisition had been its $400 million purchase of NeXt Computer, a company that Jobs founded after being ousted from Apple in the 1980s.

Cook said he never considered what Jobs would have thought about the Beats' acquisition during the negotiations. Jobs "told me to do what was right," Cook said. "And I am 100 per cent certain this is what is right. This is one of those things that we will look back upon and say it was meant to be."

Morris, who considers Iovine to be his best friend, believes Cook is making a smart move that will give Apple even more credibility in the music industry.

"It's a game changer because Jimmy is that kind of guy who can change a game," Morris said. "I am not saying he is Steve Jobs, but he is a guy with new ideas and he really knows how to build the bridge between music and technology."

But some analysts question whether Beats will be a good fit for Apple, which makes most of its money selling hardware such as iPhones and iPads.

Forrester Research analyst Frank Gillett says Apple would have been better off developing its own headphones in-house and expanding into music subscriptions through iTunes.

"It's hard to understand why Apple would have to spend $3 billion on a nascent streaming service and a line of bass-heavy headphones," Gillett says.

Yukari Iwatani Kane, the author of "Haunted Empire," an inside look at Apple since co-founder Jobs' death, also sees a disconnect.

"Culturally, Beats is the complete opposite of Apple," Kane says. "It's known for being loud and bold and in your face. It doesn't fit with Apple's understated, discerning brand."

Having visited Apple on a regular basis since he first met Jobs more than a decade ago, Iovine said he has no qualms about joining Apple.

"This is not a big company to us," Iovine said. "We can roller skate in the halls here. Dre and I have been working together for 22 years. We are not about to go somewhere where we are going to fall."

Dre was more sedate Wednesday than he was in a celebratory video posted online declaring him as hip-hop's first billionaire after news of the Apple talks leaked earlier this month. "To be able to do something that could potentially change the world, I'm thrilled."

Copyright © 2014 Times Internet Limited. All rights reserved.

18 May 09:52

Comic for May 9, 2014

18 May 09:45

South Korea has the best plastic surgeons with amazing before and after transformations

by noreply@blogger.com (brian wang)
South Korean plastic surgeons are among the best in the world. In fact they’re so good that people from other countries like China and Japan are actually having trouble getting back home.

That’s sounds really crazy, but it’s true. When most people get a nose job or a lip job, they just look like ‘enhanced’ versions of themselves. But people returning from a plastic surgery vacation in South Korea are truly transformed. You’d have to look very closely at the ‘before’ and ‘after’ photographs, and even then, it’s hard to make a connection. So I suppose you couldn’t really blame airport officials for stopping these tourists from returning home.

Korean hospitals have found a way to work around the issue. They are now handing out ‘plastic surgery certificates’ on request to overseas patients. These certificates include the patient’s passport number, the duration of stay, the name and location of the hospital and the hospital’s official seal. Travelers can use the certificate to help convince immigration officials on the return trip home.



Read more »
18 May 09:44

Good Bye Dr. Singh

by greatbong

Manmohan-Singh_1438480c

Good bye Dr. Manmohan Singh.

You had once said that you hoped that history remembers you more kindly than the present does. Given that history at least in our country is written by a cabal of  historians that are ideologically well-oriented towards your world-view and viscerally opposed to your opponents, you might very well get your wish. Be as it may, and I would not grudge you the odd hagiography, the thing is Dr. Singh I will not remember you kindly.

And let me explain why.

You failed as a leader.

National crises make even ordinary leaders like George W Bush look good. Except you could not pass for a leader even then. When our nation was in peril like as on 26/11 or our people were agitated like after the Delhi gang rape, you surfaced, almost always too late, with a prepared statement that had in it as much passion and hope and spontaneity as a tax form. Now the cynical intellectual in you may scoff at this, but alas when the country is attacked and terrorists do what they do, spread terror, ordinary people often just needs to hear a firm and reassuring voice. Yet the abiding memory of one of the most dastardly acts of aggression this country has seen will remain  your most efficient Home Minister changing his bandhgalas like Suchitra Sen changing saris in a song sequence, and the resounding sound of silence from supposedly the most powerful person in the country.

But then your friends will say you were not that kind of leader. You were never the orator, the rouser of passions, the mover of crowds. You were the quiet academic, the idea-person, the “less words more action” type of man. Even here, in your supposed strong suit, one thing must be said.

You failed as a policy-man.

Of course you may say that the economy and the world market is not in your hands and truly it isnt. But that does not fully explain why the pace of economic reforms slowed down during your tenure at the top. Prices of basic commodities shot up, industries shrunk, investor confidence in the country dissipated, and large-scale, big-ticket government schemes, transparent vote-buying exercises  were announced and implemented at massive cost to the public exchequer, the cost of which the nation will be saddled with for decades. Now you can say that “the opposition did not let me do what I want”. But a successful leader is the one with the ability to get things done despite dissent and opposition. You worked under a man who did this amazingly well, one PV Narasimha Rao, and if you remember, even though you may not want to, the economic reforms that you are rightly credited with, were also accomplished under tremendous opposition pressure and recalcitrance in the 90s.

But then that is the problem. You were never leadership material.

And yet you were made leader for precisely that.

You failed as a leader and you failed as a policy-man because that was the plan all along.  The mother made you the Prime Minister because you had no political base, no political ambition and lacked the will and the ability to leverage Prime Ministership to become popular. You were the ideal satrap, the sent-from-above throne-warmer. They wanted the son to lead and you to clean up. They wanted the policies that would lead them to consolidate vote banks to be put into place and they wanted you to take the fall out. If you didn’t fail as a leader, dear Dr. Singh, how would the son’s halo grow brighter? You were set up for failure from the very start. That’s why they chose you.

One would note down my use of the passive voice in the last paragraph. They did that. They did this. You. Well you let it happen. In a way this use of the passive voice is natural for we always associate passivity with you. Passivity. Silence. This though is the biggest escape route that history will give you, the line that you were too much a good guy, too nice a man, and that you had things be done to you.

A victim.

But no sir. I refuse to buy that.

I refuse to buy the innocent Mandakini Ram Teri Ganga Maili narrative. You are too intelligent a person not to have realized what every halfwit in the country already had. That you were being used as a surrogate, a pin-cushion by those who wanted all the credit but none of the blame. In Sanjaya Baru’s book, there is more than one reference of you being keenly aware of that and resenting it yourself.

And yet you did nothing.

You presided over the most corrupt administration in the history of this country.

And yet you did nothing. You covered up, you stayed silent, you looked away from the camera and asked “theek hai?” and all this you justified as “coalition dharma” or realpolitik, what one needs to look away from in order to rule.

But that beggars the question. Why? Why was it so important to rule when financial misadventures were happening under your very nose in the departments you yourself controlled?

It was not as if you could not do anything nor that you did not know what was going on or how it could be stopped. One of your last acts, long after the horse had bolted, was to prevent one of your esteemed ministerial colleagues from grabbing a large fistful of loot before he left.

Why didn’t you do that earlier Dr Singh? You could have blown the lid off this whole murky mess and told the people what was going on.

You did not do that.

If you think you did not have it in you to be a crusader, you could have resigned and people would have realized why.

You could then have become a leader by refusing to lead.

If that seemed too dramatic, you could have cited health reasons and stepped down. Hell you could have quietly called it a day after UPA one.

And yet you did none of the above.

You held on and kept mum and closed your eyes.  Which brings me back to the question. Why? Why when you knew so obviously how you were being used, did you overlook the worst kind of financial malfeasance?

Why did you simply not walk away?

If it was any other politician I would have known the answer. It would be so obvious that asking it would be superfluous. But in your case, your personal honesty I personally will never doubt. So what was it?

I guess the answer will probably be the power. The power of sitting on the big seat was too much to give up, even though more or less everyone knew, including yourself, that this power was only in name for you could do no good with it.

If I sound unduly harsh or bitter, it is because I am. For someone who grew up in the 90s and who was keenly interested in politics and wanted to be a politician himself (I still do), you sir were a beacon of light. You were the shining example, who was sitting at the table not because he was someone’s son or because he beat up a lot of other guys in college with hockey sticks, but because he was smarter and more educated than everyone else in that room.

It gave me, and I presume many like me, a hypothetical pathway, a hope that I don’t have to be a goon or a prince to be in politics.

Real achievement would suffice.

Well Dr Singh you just took a sledgehammer to that ideal.

Which is why I will not remember you kindly.

You failed me.