Tom Roche
Shared posts
Behind the News – June 30, 2016
Tom Rocheunfortunately (and inexplicably) this is the same as the previous week
The Secret of Our Success [Audio]
Tom Rocheexcellent
Blaming Putin after BREXIT. Stephen F. Cohen, NYU, Princeton University, EastWestAccord.com.
Tom RocheAt end, Cohen discusses the March 1991 USSR referendum ( sketched here https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Soviet_Union_referendum,_1991 ) and its aftermath, rarely mentioned in USCFM.
Democracy Now! 2016-06-29 Wednesday
Tom Rocheesp last piece, James Steele from Center for Investigative Reporting on "Who Got Rich Off the Student Debt Crisis" on the privatization of Sallie Mae. Amy said there will be a web part 2.
Democracy Now! 2016-06-29 Wednesday
- Headlines for June 29, 2016
- "A Dark Day for the People of Puerto Rico": U.S. Senate Moves to OK "Colonial Control Board"
- Meet the Attorney Who Just Won the Historic Abortion Rights Case at the Supreme Court
- Former Chilean Army Officer Found Liable for 1973 Murder of Víctor Jara After U.S.-Backed Coup
- Who Is Getting Rich Off the $1.3 Trillion Student Debt Crisis?
How do we learn better: digital or print?
Tom RocheInteresting paper by Kauffman (CMU HCII) and Flanagan (Dartmouth Tiltfactor) claims high-level evaluation/construal (~= global/abstract assessment) of material is better when presented in hardcopy (print on paper) than softcopy (pixels on screens). See blog post @ http://www.americanradioworks.org/how-do-we-learn-better-digital-or-print/ (archived @ http://web.archive.org/web/20160626211739/http://www.americanradioworks.org/how-do-we-learn-better-digital-or-print/ ) which also links to the paper, which is unfortunately paywalled.
Acting 101: Country and language need not match!
Tom RocheFoad HP is marginally better (at least, more different) than Lianne Mauladin (who does straight-up standup about as well as it can be), but both are excellent.
Reinventing “wife beaters” and tackling dyslexia.
Tom RocheExcellent episode. Starts with Todd Butler doing his festival-season song, then Phil Hanley (no songs), then DeAnne Smith (who mostly does her "no worries" song), then Todd Butler does his "Car Tune."
The Politicians and the Egalitarians: The Hidden History of American Politics by @seanwilentz. @Princeton
Tom RocheUnfortunately no discussion of Wilentz' new book. Fortunately, interesting compare/contrast of the US Whig party in the 1850s and the Republicans since ~2010.
Welcome to the age of Trump
Tom Rocheby Jonathan Freedland, text @ https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2016/may/19/welcome-to-the-age-of-trump
Alternatives to Austerity? [Audio]
Tom RocheAt best, mostly the yammering of anthropologists; at worst, destructive talk. Bear, Muehlebach, and Schuster are the anthropologists. Coote is from the New Economics Foundation, which makes some interesting points, but only as goals--no policy here. The worst was when one of them valorized Dubliners who are objecting not merely to privatizing water (which is right and just) but even to metering water use and billing for it by use, rather than socializing the cost. This is of course not "sticking it to the man," but sticking it to the *planet*.
How an aggressive interrogation can make you a murderer
Tom Rochebegins well, but then 'To continue reading this premium article, subscribe for unlimited access.'
Democrats scored. Foodies scolded. Egyptians empowered. States judged. @DanHenninger. @HenryIMiller @EricTrager18. Eileen Norcross, @Mercatus.
Tom RocheDelete first half (Dan Heinninger's diatribe about Orlando Massacre and the Democrats), but Henry Miller on problems with Whole Foods (beginning @ 9:30) will confirm everything you suspected about libertarian John Mackey's empire. Unfortunately it ends with Batchelor and Miller moaning about organic and anti-GMO hysteria and "foodie authoritarianism," but that's the price one pays for listening to JBS.
NATO Baits Russia. Michael Vlahos, John Hopkins. @JHUWorldCrisis.
Tom Rochebad link: it actually downloads the following Heinninger et al piece
Behind the News, 6/16/16
Tom RocheI guess it had to happen: a wasted hour of Behind the News. Richard Seymour seems to want to make a left case for Brexit, but mostly just digresses. (For a truly left case for Brexit, listen to Chris Bickerton's "The European Union: a citizen's guide" @ http://media.rawvoice.com/lse_publiclecturesandevents/richmedia.lse.ac.uk/publiclecturesandevents/20160615_1830_theEuropeanUnion.mp3 ) Virginia Heffernan (a Harvard PhD in English lit with a NYT Magazine column!) wants to make a lit-crit-sorta valorization of "the Internet," but mostly just makes casual misunderstandings: the technology behind the Internet and the Web, confusing the DIY technology/stance behind hip-hop with that which was *not* behind disco, etc.
Behind the News – June 16, 2016
Tom RocheI guess it had to happen: a wasted hour of Behind the News. Richard Seymour seems to want to make a left case for Brexit, but mostly just digresses. Virginia Heffernan (a Harvard PhD in English lit with a NYT Magazine column!) wants to make a lit-crit-sorta valorization of "the Internet," but mostly just makes casual misunderstandings: the technology behind the Internet and the Web, confusing the DIY technology/stance behind hip-hop with that which was *not* behind disco, etc.
What Sir John Kerr did after The Dismissal
Tom Rochesleazier and sleazier ... not just Kerr but also Queen Elizabeth!
The Kennedy Assassination Tapes by Max Holland. @washdecoded
Tom RocheGood piece, but has nothing to do with the Kennedy Assassination Tapes. Rather, Holland and Batchelor discuss the Zapruder film, and particularly why other evidence shows that the film's famous 6 seconds show only the 2nd and 3rd shots Oswald fired, not all 3.
How Uber conquered London
The gangsters on England's doorstep
The Enright Files - The Donald Trump Phenomenon
Tom RocheDavid Frum (first guest) is surprisingly insightful.
How the Pentagon punished NSA whistleblowers
Tom RocheExcellent piece by Mark Hertsgaard, see {transcript, original article} @ http://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2016/may/22/how-pentagon-punished-nsa-whistleblowers
Media Trumpwash Clinton’s Reckless Foreign Record
Tom RocheAdam Johnson covers HRC's past transgressions relatively well (absent Haiti, which was mostly absent from this piece, as well as lesser sins like Paraguay and the Maldives), but misses the most important, most dangerous part of Hillary's current foreign/military policy. Obama, with Clinton's active support both in and out of DoS and on this campaign, is pushing toward war with both China and Russia. Aside from being a breathtakingly stupid imperial overreach (comparable to Hitler declaring war on both the US and the Soviet Union), Hillary (and the Democratic establishment that loves her) flirts with a nuclear WW3.

Hillary Clinton’s support for regime change in countries like Iraq, Libya, Syria and Honduras is seldom recalled when comparing her foreign policy to Donald Trump’s. (photo: David J. Marshall/US Army)
Former Secretary of State Hillary Clinton gave a much-anticipated “foreign policy” speech (6/2/16) in which she took presumptive Republican nominee Donald Trump to task for what she called his “dangerously incoherent” foreign policy stances. The speech was widely met with praise from the pundit class:
- Hillary Clinton Rolled Out the Anti-Trump Argument That Could Deliver a Landslide: Vox
- Hillary Clinton Just Kicked Trump in the Shins: And Showed That She’s Certainly Tough Enough for the Long Haul: Slate
- Hillary Clinton Just Proved She Is Very Good at Taunting Donald Trump: Washington Post
- Hillary Clinton Eviscerates Donald Trump in Her Best Speech Yet: Huffington Post
- Clinton Targets the ‘Blame America First’ Republicans: Bloomberg View
Almost all of the praise was premised on two assumptions: A) Trump presents a horrific risk to the planet and B) Clinton is the antidote to this, a “steady hand” in a dangerous world.
Point A, it’s worth emphasizing, is true. Trump’s Muslim immigration ban and his claim that climate change is an “expensive hoax” that was “created by and for the Chinese” are certifiable and racist. His plan to seize the natural resources of other countries reverts us back to outright 19th century colonialism. His violent and inciting rhetoric presents a clear danger to immigrants, women and people of color.
But B, the idea that Clinton is, by contrast, a prudent foreign policy moderate, is an establishment media assertion with little or no supporting evidence.
Clinton has a long, objectively verifiable track record of acting recklessly on matters of foreign policy that seems to have slipped into a memory hole as the prospect of a Trump presidency looms overhead. While one would expect this rewriting of history to come from Clinton surrogates, it’s increasingly bizarre coming from nominally independent media pundits.

Matthew Yglesias in Vox (6/2/16): “You can at least be sure that a Clinton presidency won’t lead to some enormous unforeseen cataclysm.”
Over at Vox, Matt Yglesias has positioned Clinton as the sensible, reliable choice on foreign policy and, in doing so, failed to mention Iraq, Libya, Syria, Honduras or any other of the list of nations that Clinton has helped to make, in some capacity or another, much worse off. When comparing the high stakes of statecraft, Yglesias even laid out this ahistorical comparison:
But at the end of the day, even though real estate is a game for risk takers, it’s also a game where the downside risk is very limited. At the absolute worst, you can’t repay your debts and it becomes a bit harder to get a loan the next time.
Running a country isn’t like that. If you make a big mistake, you can’t just go to court and have the slate wiped clean. A casino bankruptcy hurts the bottom line of a few banks. A sovereign default of the United States — something Trump has floated — would destroy the global economy.
But “wiping the slate clean” is exactly what Iraq War boosters have done. Bush and Rumsfeld are currently playing golf, while those who supported the war, like Clinton, continue to hold positions of power. Clinton issued a belated and perfunctory apology—and that was it. And that’s just the one “mistake” she’s been called to answer for. Clinton’s support of a right-wing coup in Honduras, or the disastrous regime change in Libya, are seldom brought up, much less apologized for.
Perhaps Yglesias is referencing the material consequences to the world, rather than to the politician, but if this is the case, then why not address the hundreds of thousands of dead Iraqis resulting from the war Clinton pushed? Why not bring up the disastrous government she forced upon Haiti? Yglesias is right: The stakes are high, and, time and time again, Clinton has made decisions that resulted in material harm.
Slate’s Fred Kaplan and Bloomberg View’s Eli Lake also neglected to mention the Iraq War when recapping Clinton’s “experience.” It could be because they, like Yglesias, also pushed for that particular disaster. Indeed, as we’ve seen before, to indemnify Clinton for her past “bad judgments,” is to do the same for most of the pundit class who also followed Bush off the cliff. Her rebranding is their rebranding. This may serve immediate political interests—especially if one views Trump as existentially dangerous—but it doesn’t serve history, and it certainly doesn’t serve readers.
The media has a duty to vet the foreign policy record and plans of the respective candidates. As such, the pundits are right to pinpoint some of Trump’s more dangerous plans. Where they’ve consistently fallen short—and this was on full display in response to Thursday’s speech—is also contextualizing and harshly critiquing Clinton’s brand of measured, polite recklessness.
On this we have some pretty stark examples. The right-wing coup Clinton backed in Honduras in 2009 eventually led to the assassination of indigenous leaders and displacement of thousands of Hondurans as they fled right-wing violence.
One email from her aide Sid Blumenthal in March 2011 informed then-Secretary Clinton that a Libyan rebel commander told him that “his troops continue to summarily execute all foreign mercenaries captured in the fighting.” (“Foreign mercenaries” being code for black Africans loyal to Gaddafi). In response, the State Department continued to support the rebels without any clear concern for their war crimes. A BBC report that December detailed how 30,000 black Libyans were ethnically cleansed from the town of Misrata. A report the following year in the New York Times detailed how US arms “fell into the hands of jihadis” in an effort to overthrow Gaddafi.
Clinton’s eagerness to back dubious groups in the interest of regime change wouldn’t stop there. For years, the State Department watched Qatar and Saudi Arabia arm jihadists in Syria while pledging millions to overthrow the Syrian government themselves. Time and time again, Clinton’s desire to overthrow unfriendly governments resulted in arms “ending up in the hands” of designated terrorist organizations.
As for the former Secretary’s famous “wonkishness,” there’s evidence, as Peter Beinart noted in The Atlantic in 2014, that Clinton didn’t even review the NIE report on Iraqi weapons of mass destruction before voting to authorize the war in October 2002.
Unlike Trump’s rhetoric, these were actual reckless decisions that affected real people. Of course, media should critique Trump’s outlandish, ofttimes cartoonish campaign promises. But they don’t have to whitewash Clinton’s foreign policy record to do so.
Adam Johnson is a contributing analyst for FAIR.org. He’s on Twitter at @AdamJohnsonNYC.
Iraqi, U.S.-Led Forces Push to Retake Fallujah
Tom RocheGuests seem to skew rightwing:
- John Arquilla, chairman of the defense analysis department, Naval Postgraduate School; author of "Insurgents, Raiders and Bandits: How Masters of Irregular Warfare Have Shaped Our World"
- James Jeffrey, fellow, Washington Institute for Near East Policy; U.S. ambassador to Iraq from 2010 to 2012
- Ahmed Maher, Baghdad correspondent, BBC World Service
- Michael Pregent, adjunct fellow, Hudson Institute; former intelligence advisor to General David Petraeus
Fighting is intensifying in the Iraq city of Fallujah as the Iraqi military and U.S.-led forces attempt to wrest control from ISIS militants. Aid groups report that at least 50,000 civilians remain trapped in Fallujah, which is facing extreme food, water and medicine shortages. We discuss the offensive and U.S. policy in the region.
Behind the News – June 2, 2016
Tom RocheKeeanga-Yamahtta Taylor on Black Lives Matter and black liberation
The inside story of Facebook’s biggest setback
Tom RocheExcellent exposure of the frauds that are Mark Zuckerberg, Facebook, and this particular scam to advance Facebook's market share while destroying net neutrality (which Indians have upheld much more straightforwardly than have Americans). Read the transcript @ https://www.theguardian.com/technology/2016/may/12/facebook-free-basics-india-zuckerberg
Where The Presidential Candidates Stand On Key Issues
Tom RocheSome truly appalling Bernie-bashing from guests Norman Ornstein (probably the least partisan member of AEI, but still AEI), Ruth Marcus (WaPo, aka "Fox News Print Edition"), and Byron York (Washington Examiner, apparently a clone of the Washington Times minus the Unification Church). Even York (who occasionally remembers he's there for pro-Trump balance) is obviously in the tank for Hillary.
Democracy Now! 2016-05-26 Thursday
Tom RocheGood first piece (after headlines) with Michael Tracey on how Hillary Clinton's email scandal is certainly a bigger deal than has been portrayed either by her campaign or by the corporate-funded media, and is the subject of an ongoing FBI investigation. Tracey exposes false and contradictory statements made by Hillary and her campaign, esp regarding whistleblowers.
Democracy Now! 2016-05-26 Thursday
- Headlines for May 26, 2016
- "Significant Security Risks": State Department Says Clinton Broke Rules Using Private Email Server
- Granddaughter of Exxon Scientist Confronts CEO over Oil Giant’s Decision to Fund Climate Lies
- Bill McKibben on Exxon, the Power of Divestment, and Being Targeted by Shadowy Right-Wing Group
- Keep Oil in the Soil: Bill McKibben on Being Named by Sanders to DNC Platform Committee
- Texas and 10 Other States Escalate Attacks on Trans People with "Political Stunt" Bathroom Lawsuit
Tudormania: Why can’t we get over it?
Tom RocheInteresting piece on the "Merrie England shtick" and good and bad history. See full {transcript, original article} @ http://www.theguardian.com/news/2016/may/04/tudormania-why-can-we-not-get-over-it