That’s Safety Mom on the right, pushing ADT Pulse on the Today Show without revealing she was paid by the alarm company.
According to a Federal Trade Commission complaint [PDF], home security biggie ADT paid a total of $300,000 to three different experts — 2/3 of that total to one expert alone — to make TV and radio appearances to shill for the ADT Pulse system. In addition to the cash, two of the human advertisements received $4,000 worth of security equipment from ADT as compensation.
Even though ADT booked these dozens of media appearances, offering interview suggestions and B-roll footage to interviewers, the segments featuring these experts rarely mentioned any connection to the alarm company, instead describing the guests as experts in child safety, home security, and technology who were there to share their professional advice; not shill for a product.
In fact, the FTC alleges that ADT sometimes took steps to deliberately make it even less obvious that these experts were being paid to push the company’s product.
“The paid spokesperson sometimes demonstrated other child safety, home security, or technology products, in addition to the ADT Pulse, adding to the impression that the spokesperson was providing an impartial, expert review of products,” reads the complaint.
The FTC provides examples of one expert, the author of the SafetyMom.com site, who appeared on the Today Show as a “national family and safety expert,” touting the features of the Pulse system to show hosts Hoda Kotb and Kathie Lee Gifford.
During the segment, Safety Mom talks up the features of the service and its affordability; she even says “It’s amazing!” but is never identified as a paid spokesperson or endorser of the product.
According to the terms of the proposed deal with ADT [PDF], the alarm company is prohibited from misrepresenting that any discussion or demonstration of a security or monitoring product or service is an independent review provided by an impartial expert. It must also make clear and prominent disclosures about any relationship between an endorser and the company.
ADT must also remove reviews and endorsements that have been misrepresented as independently provided by an impartial expert or that fail to disclose a material connection between ADT and an endorser.
“It’s hard for consumers to make good buying decisions when they think they’re getting independent expert advice as part of an impartial news segment and have no way of knowing they are actually watching a sales pitch,” said Jessica Rich, Director of the FTC’s Bureau of Consumer Protection. “When a paid endorser appears in a news or talk show segment with the host of that program, the relationship with the advertiser must be clearly disclosed.”
Of course, we can’t do a story about disingenuous endorsements without including a little Mass Effect:
Pilot Barbie will not accept nasty notes from sexist passengers.
The workbook and games that go along with this project/marketing campaign/whatever the heck it is notes that it’s all funded by “a generous grant from Mattel.” Really, now. It features Barbie and her dark-haired but light-skinned friends in the outfits of Barbie’s various careers over the decades. Yes, yes, women can become astronauts (with hot pink trim on their spacesuits) or pilots (who wear Mary Janes with high heels.)
Here’s the game’s presentation of workwear for a veterinarian, for example:
My pets’ vet has a long blonde ponytail, but she generally puts on some pants to go to work.
It’s laudable to teach girls that they can grow up to become whatever they want. The problem is that girls are asked to identify people who perform various jobs by what they wear, and those outfits have a lot less fabric and a lot more pink than what real pediatricians and pilots wear to work every day.
For a campaign that measures up people by what they wear, it’s interesting that the end result is a patch (not a badge, at least) that scouts can wear on the back of their uniform. The patch is not subtle.
It’s cute, but it sure is a Barbie ad. “it is particularly troubling that Daisies and Brownies, the youngest Scouts, are encouraged to wear a Barbie patch, transforming their previously commercial-free uniforms into a walking ad,” notes a petition started against the Barbie project launched by the Campaign for a Commercial-Free Childhood and Center for a New American Dream.Take Our Poll
Police search for bank robber in Nokesville
A man with a red mustache, and wearing a "South Park" hoodie, robbed the Carter Bank and Trust in Nokesville late Thursday morning. The robber walked into the bank at 12912 Fitzwater Drive around 11:30 a.m., implied he had a weapon and demanded ...
Carter Bank Robbed in NokesvillePotomacLocal.com
all 2 news articles »
Glass Shattered at Wireless Jungle
At approximately 9:31PM on March 4, 2014 Manassas City Police responded to an alarm at Wireless Jungle located at 9526 Liberia Ave. Upon arrival, officers discovered that someone(s) had gained entry by breaking the glass of the locked front door with a ...
Note to Burglars: These Aren't the Phones You're Looking ForPatch.com
all 2 news articles »